Study Shows Race, Not Experience, Impacts Hiring In Sports World

Heidi GrappendorfNEWS RELEASE – July 7, 2010
For More Information:
Caroline Barnhill  /  News Services  / 919.515.6251 caroline_barnhill@ncsu.edu
Dr. Heidi Grappendorf  /  919.513.0060  heidi_grappendorf@ncsu.edu

If you want to get your foot in the door of the sports industry, your race may mean more than your experience. That’s the major result of a new study from North Carolina State University that examined hiring decisions for entry-level sports management positions.

“Previous research has shown that management positions in the sports industry continue to be dominated by white males – and that a prejudice against blacks in managerial positions exists because of a perceived ‘lack of fit’ between being black and being a manager or leader,” explains Dr. Heidi Grappendorf, assistant professor of parks, recreation and tourism management at NC State. “We wanted to find out – when all other factors were considered equal – what  impact  race had on hiring for entry-level sports management positions.”

In the study, researchers created one-page resumes for fictitious job applicants. The resumes  all included identical work and education experience, but changed factors such as race, sex and previous participation as an athlete. The results showed resumes with traditional black names rated significantly lower than their white counterparts in terms of overall likeability, competency and likelihood of being hired.

The study showed male athletes benefit most from having an athletic background – as they have been evaluated as more competent for upper-level positions when compared to male non-athletes, female athletes and female non-athletes with identical athletic qualifications. While white male athletes did not receive significantly higher ratings than the other applicants (i.e., both blacks and whites), they did receive the highest ratings of all groups in both hiring and competence ratings.

“Our findings indicated that for black males and females, athletic participation provided no advantage in hiring recommendations,” Grappendorf says. “Clearly, athletic participation is not ‘superseding’ race. This contradicts previous findings indicating that the athletic role could be beneficial in the hiring process.”

Grappendorf and fellow researchers Laura Burton, from the University of Connecticut, and Angela Henderson, from the University of Northern Colorado, recently presented their findings at the 2010 North American Society of Sport Management Conference.

NC State’s Department of Parks, Recreation and Tourism Management is part of the university’s College of Natural Resources.

-barnhill-

Note to editors: The study abstract follows.

“Examining the Influence of Race, Gender, and Athletic Participation on Hiring Preferences in Sport Management”

Authors: Heidi Grappendorf, North Carolina State University; Laura Burton, University of Connecticut; and Angela Henderson, University of Northern Colorado

Presented: June 3, 2010, North American Society of Sport Management Conference in Tampa, Fla.

Abstract: Lapchick (2008), in the Racial and Gender Report Card that reports the hiring practices of women and people of color in leading sports organizations, reported that representation of racial minorities at NCAA institutions declined in comparison to previous report cards. In addition, the majority of general managers, senior administrators, and professional administrators in major league sports continue to be dominated by White males (Lapchick). Overall, there exists significant racial inequality in the general United States labor market (Bertrand & Mullainathan, 2004). Studies have shown that when employers were faced with a White and a Black applicant who share similar educational backgrounds and work experience, the White applicant was more likely to be chosen for employment and that employer prejudice or the perception of race may signal lower productivity of the Black applicants (Bertrand & Mullainathan). Prejudice can arise from the relations that people perceive between the characteristics of members of a social group and the requirements of the social roles that group members occupy (Eagly & Karau, 2002). When perceivers hold a stereotype about a social group that is incongruent with the attributes that are thought to be required for success in certain classes of social roles, a potential for prejudice exists. These stereotypes may potentially affect how males and females perceive Blacks in management and could even impact how they are judged once they enter the workforce.

NC State Wood Products Extension to Offer Lumber Quality Workshop

hardwood lumber being processedNEWS RELEASE
Wood Products Extension
North Carolina State University

WHAT:   Drying Hardwood Lumber Update – A One Day Workshop for Improving Lumber Quality
WHEN:   September 22, 2010
WHERE:  Wood Education & Resource Center,  Princeton, West Virginia

In these challenging markets many lumber manufacturers and secondary wood producers are changing their species mix in order to remain cost effective. Many of these species are prone to stain and warp. Some such as oak are prone to checking. North Carolina State University’s Wood Products Extension in conjunction with the US Forest Service’s Wood Education & Resource Center will hold a one day workshop to update dry kiln operators so they can produce a higher quality product.

log pileThe one day workshop will be divided into two sessions. The morning session will focus on oak drying including problems such as drying green and partially pre-dried lumber as well as drying thicker stock. The afternoon session will emphasize drying white woods including avoiding stain, stacking procedures that produce flat lumber, low temperature drying schedules that produce quality results and equalizing and conditioning that produce lumber that is flat and stress free.

The workshop is sponsored by and will be taught at the Wood Education & Resource Center in Princeton, West Virginia on September 22, 2010. The course is co-sponsored by the Southeastern Dry Kiln Club.

For more information: Joe Denig, North Carolina State University, Campus Box 8003, Raleigh, NC 27695, telephone (919) 515-5582, Fax (919) 515-8739

Visit Wood Products Extension on the web at: http://www.ces.ncsu.edu/nreos/wood/

NCSU Study Abroad Faculty Spotlight is on Dr. Susan Moore

Susan Moore on boat during study abroadDr. Susan Moore may be feeling some heat lately, but it is not just the summer sun. The NC State University Study Abroad Office is shining their Spotlight on Susan as this season's featured Faculty Director. Dr. Moore is Extension Associate Professor and Director of the Forestry &
Environmental Outreach Program in the Department of Forestry &
Environmental Resources in the College of Natural
Resources, and her  international experience includes work in Japan, forestry study
tours to Ecuador and Guatemala, and ongoing research and extension
work in Southern Chile.

Learn more about Susan, her Study Abroad Program in Southern Chile, and her advice to students!

 Find out what is happening in the Forestry and Environmental Outreach Program (FEOP), which is directed by Susan.

Susan Moore and fellow faculty in Chile 

Hands-on experiences create unique lessons in Nicaragua Study Abroad

by Dr. Chris MoormanNCSU students learned how to make tortillas. Whose is the best?

During spring break 2010, eight students in Fisheries and Wildlife Sciences and one student from Zoology traveled on a 9-day study abroad trip to Nicaragua to learn about the country’s people and culture, wildlife, ecotourism industry, and local coffee production. The unique opportunity was offered through a partnership between NCSU and EcoQuest Travels. Trip leaders Chris Moorman, John Connors, and John Gerwin facilitated student learning, but the hands-on experiences did most of the teaching. For the first five nights, the group stayed at the Finca Esperanza Verde outside of San Ramon, Nicaragua. The Finca has rustic but beautiful accommodations and fantastic Nicaraguan food. Finca Esperanza Verde is a shade-coffee plantation and hosts eco-tourists from countries around the world. While at the Finca, the group learned about shade-grown coffee production, captured and banded birds using mist nets, saw other wildlife such as an eyelash viper and olingos, and got to know the local Nicaraguan staff.

Two keel-billed toucans 
eating fruitThe next two nights, students stayed in Granada, the oldest settlement in Central America. The group visited two volcanoes in the area – the active Volcan Masaya and Volcan Mombacho. On the first afternoon in Granada, students took a sunset boat tour of Las Isletas, small islands in Lake Nicaragua that were created by a past eruption of Mombacho. The next day, the group visited Domitila Wildlife Reserve, the first private reserve created in Nicaragua. Domitila offers one of the best examples of dry, tropical forest in Central America. The last night of the trip, everyone stayed at Montibelli Nature Preserve near Managua.

Montibelli is another example of dry tropical forest but lies at a higher elevation than Domitila. While at Montibelli, students caught over six bats species in mist nets, saw two species of mouse opossums, and learned about pineapple production. The trip was a great success; the group saw or banded over 200 species of birds (over 70 individuals banded), saw or captured 23 species of mammals (heard or saw mantled howler monkeys at five different locations), and saw or captured 25 species of reptiles and amphibians. Although most Nicaraguans are very poor, they are friendly and welcoming. The students were excellent and each brought a unique perspective to the experience. Plans are to offer the trip again during spring break 2012.

– Excerpt from student journal – “… for the majority of the day, I wasn’t thinking about the travel or home. I had missed a few people, but the trip was still so vivid in my mind that it was hard to think of much else. If I had the money, I would have bought one of the Los Isletas islands and moved in permanently. The entire trip has just left my head swimming or that may be from the exhaustion of writing this at 1:00AM. Still, the trip has given me some sort of direction in my life. Whether for good or bad, I am no longer content to simply live my life. I used to see life as a sort of race where one tried to do their best till the end, but now I want to make my life meaningful, to have an impact. I don’t care if that impact is small or large, affecting one person or many, I just want to make a difference.”This female royal flycatcher was an incredible capture that did  
it’s cobra dance when in the hand

Read more about study abroad and international opportunities in the Department of Forestry and Environmental Resources.

 Learn more about Fisheries, Wildlife, and Conservation Biology at NC State University

 Read the latest edition of the NCSU Fisheries & Wildlife Newsletter

All photos courtesy of Dr. Chris Moorman (from top to bottom: NCSU students learned how to make tortillas; two keel-billed toucans eating fruit; female royal flycatcher was an incredible capture that did it’s cobra dance when in the hand; fruit bat; vine snake).

 Fruit bat

Vine snake

Afghan Scholar Visits NC State College of Natural Resources

From Global Eyes- Summer 2010
by Roger Moore
 
Adgan forestry professor Nesar KohestaniNesar Kohestani, a forestry professor at Kabul University in Afghanistan, traveled to NC State this March to share ideas and develop professional contacts with faculty and students from the College of Natural Resources (CNR).  His visit was part of his broader participation in a US Department of Agriculture Faculty Exchange Program.

Read the full article in NC State's Global Eyes Newsletter